Can we trust the BBC?

The British Broadcasting Corporation is the UK’s biggest media outlet

Is the BBC biased? It’s interesting that in the UK, people generally assume the media to be trustworthy reporters presenting news that is of objective importance. The mainstream print media covers a wide political spectrum, from the Daily Mail and Daily Telegraph which present generally conservative views, to the left wing outlooks of the Daily Mirror and The Guardian.

However, broadcasting media is dominated by one huge corporation: the corporation, Auntie, the BBC. 93% of the population of the United Kingdom use a BBC provided service at least once a week. A whopping 256 million people worldwide receive their news from the BBC in some form, that’s a staggering one in twenty-eight. This is an astronomical figure, and the BBC’s reputation and renown for impartiality even in wartime is a key factor in retaining such a wide usage-but in recent years this reputation has come under increasing attack. Is the BBC really a trustworthy source for information with regards to key issues? Put simply, can we trust the news the BBC presents?

256 million people worldwide use a BBC News service at least once a week

The simple answer is yes and no. The BBC’s facts are impeccable the vast majority of the time, and errors are almost exclusively in good faith and corrections rapidly issued. Despite this, the BBC can be sometimes seen to have a subtle agenda, which is often unnoticed even by those in charge of the content produced there-but this bias can be seen to exist.

I recently read Robin Aitken’s fascinating take on neutrality within the corporation, Can we Trust the BBC?. The answer, he concluded, was that it has an agenda which can be clearly seen when empirical evidence is examined; Aitken states that the BBC is:

passionately against racism, in favour of ‘human rights’, supportive of internationalism, suspicious of traditional British identity and consequently strongly pro-EU; it is feminist, secular and allergic to established authority whether in the form of the Crown, the courts, the police or the churches

One may query what the problem with that is. Indeed, it is undeniable that several of these things are progressive viewpoints to be applauded, such as the condemnation of racism and upholding human rights. Things such as human rights are all well and good, until you come to the small question of interpretation-how far do you go? Are immigrants granted full rights? Can Parliament suspend rights? What rights do suspected terrorists have? The BBC has to report on these issues as and when they flare up, and when they do it is very hard to do so with an entirely neutral stance.

Aitken’s 2007 exposé of the “institutional bias” present within the BBC

Aitken’s evidence for this ‘institutional bias’ is multi-faceted. He gives evidence of a suppression of the views of ‘The Despised Tribes’-who include “the whites in Africa”, “Mr Le Pen’s supporters in France”, “American ‘Christian fundamentalists'”, “conservative Roman Catholics”, and “UKIP”. The Irish unionists are also said to have had their views suppressed, the interests of peace in Ireland and the inherent glamour of the republican cause apparently appealing to the BBC more than the conservative nature of unionism.

The concept itself is intriguing to think about. Even such mundane things as the ordering of news stories in an outlet can shape our perceptions of the importance of different causes, the limiting of interview time and omission of important context whilst reporting on the ‘wrong’ viewpoint all help to subtly colour the consumer’s views to the same shade as the BBC’s-that is, “broadly ‘progressive'”. Even this mild trend in the BBC of slightly off centre liberalism would be perfectly acceptable in the odd programme, but it is a universal trend throughout the corporation.

At present the BBC can be read to be left-leaning in a worryingly plausible way. An institution that produces news for such a gargantuan audience worldwide needs to be clear of bias, and, though there are some issues with Aitken’s argument (not least his own failure to sufficiently present the opposition’s view); it is hard to argue after reading and viewing the evidence he gives that the BBC does not need to change. Given the rapidly approaching referendum on the UK’s part in or out of the EU, that change needs to come sooner rather than later.

8 thoughts on “Can we trust the BBC?

    1. It’s a little more understandable in mainstream media apart from the BBC, the views of the owner seem to bleed through into their presentation of the news. The BBC is meant to be a politically neutral group though and is paid for by the taxpayer, which makes it a bit more dubious for it not to be neutral…
      Best wishes, Matt

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Facinating post and lots to think about. Everyone has their own viewpoint and this can’t fail to be reflected in the news even though BBC editors have guidelines to smooth out the most obvious prejudices. Our local BBC TV station spends so much air time discussing NHS issues it is either a bias or lack of other news.

    When we’re in Crete we watch BBC World, and feel better informed on worldwide events. It brings home how the news in UK concentrates on high level topical world news from a parochial view point. What bugs me about BBC World is, it’s free! Therefore, our UK licence fee is subsidising worldwide viewers. Oooh, I’ll get off my soap box now! X

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think the theory is that a little bias in each programme is inevitable, but if they have a little bias each way it cancels out-though obviously they would prefer no bias. Are there adverts on BBC World? I hadn’t realised that it was paid for by licence fees! Feel free to rant here (or in a post…), I’m always interested to hear what people think.
      Best wishes, Matt

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Ah, of course adverts! See, like most biased people I didn’t let a few facts get in the way of a good rant! BBC World is free to viewers and advertising is so slick I didn’t ‘see’ them. There are adverts on the BBC website when viewed outside of the UK. I’ll get back in my box now! X

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s